How Good Were the Hanson Brothers?
My favourite minor scene in Slap Shot comes right before that guy bellowing "you goons, you can't skate" throws his keys. The three bespectacled ruffians score a fine team goal, the guy beans Jeff, and more movie magic happens as the Hanson brothers climb into the stands to beat the tar out of every opposing fan who crosses their fists, including coincidentally the right one.
I like it because Slap Shot is fictional[citation needed] but the cast was as legitimate as some of the stories. Michael Ontkean looks credible as the skilled Ned Braden because he was a quality NCAA scorer who could have played senior hockey if he'd wanted to (glad though we Twin Peaks fans are that he didn't). The camera sensibly doesn't show the other real actors trying anything more ambitious than skating in circles or dumping the puck in, but between Ontkean, the Hansons, and the famous parade of goons in the final game we see guys who could have been, and often were, paid to play hockey in real life, firing gloves off and having stick fights. A movie of minor-leaguers who could play pretty well playing pretty well is not interesting; a movie of minor-leaguers who could play pretty well hammering a drunk guy into the boards until he wets himself definitely is, but just once in a while the movie calls attention to the fact that these players are not actually jokes. The Hansons' goal is the best-looking hockey play in the movie, which is what you'd expect because they were the best hockey players.
The Hanson Brothers, registered trademark, are Steve Carlson, Jeff Carlson, and Dave Hanson, who replaced Jack Carlson in the movie because Jack missed filming to play major league hockey. Slap Shot gave them a stylized but reasonable portrayal. Slap Shot is the all-American hockey movie, with its dying mill town, its fashion shows, and its empty old rinks, and all four "Hanson brothers" are American. Jack Carlson and Dave Hanson were definitely goons, but Steve Carlson was a skill player, and Jeff was a well-rounded minor pro. The fictional Hanson Brothers were never more at home than punching people in half-empty arenas; the real foursome, like in that one scene, showed spots of ability. All got at least a cup of coffee in the big leagues and three of the four had a sort of career. Heck with it, it's April 1, let's capture the spirit of the thing. How good were the Hanson Brothers?


